Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

Analysts read Bilawal's remarks as hint of new opposition bloc

MQM-P's Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui rejected the PPP chairman's warning of bloodshed over new provinces and asked courts to take suo motu notice.

Skardu Times desk
Analysts read Bilawal's remarks as hint of new opposition bloc
Photo: Aaj News

Pakistan Peoples Party chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's call this week for the release of political prisoners, including former prime minister Imran Khan, and his opposition to dividing Sindh have been read by analysts as a sign of a possible new opposition alliance, while MQM-P leader Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui called his warning of bloodshed over new provinces a threat to all of Pakistan.

Bilawal met journalists at the Karachi Press Club and appeared on 'Meet the Press', where he described Imran Khan as a political prisoner, defended Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (F) chief Maulana Fazlur Rehman's right to criticise the government, rejected any division of Sindh and called for the political system to be reset by democratic means.

Mazhar Abbas, a senior journalist and analyst, told Independent Urdu that the PPP has been and remains part of the system, but that Bilawal's remarks showed he is not satisfied with it. He said the positions taken on Imran Khan and on Fazlur Rehman pointed to a new opposition alliance, though it remains to be seen how effective it would be and what course the PML-N takes. Both parties, he said, should keep their differences short of enmity because they may need each other again.

Mazhar Abbas also said the PPP's closeness to the PML-N and the PML-Q cost it position in Punjab, and that in building ties with other parties it neglected its own organisation and workers.

He said Bilawal's clear stance against dividing Sindh was well received, but that he should have avoided the word "bloodshed", since Sindh has already seen too much.

Dr Riaz Shaikh, dean of the faculty of social sciences at the Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology in Karachi, told Independent Urdu that the PPP's difficulty is that after the 2008 election it narrowed from a national party to one based in Sindh and south Punjab. If it cannot hold even that base, its room will shrink further, he said, pointing to the Awami National Party's reduced space in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

Dr Shaikh said protecting Sindh's unity is tied to the PPP's political survival, and that a hard line on the issue could also be part of political bargaining. He said there is room for negotiation on the National Finance Commission award and local government powers, and that the PPP and the MQM could discuss an effective local government system in Karachi and Hyderabad.

At a press conference in Karachi on Thursday, Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui said an argument is not answered with a threat and that Sindh's cities would not be allowed to become anyone's estate. He said the demand for new provinces is no longer confined to urban Sindh and has become a need of the whole country, and that provinces, like districts and divisions, are administrative units even as they are being treated increasingly as states.

He asked why bloodshed is invoked when provinces are demanded, said the statement was a threat to all of Pakistan and called on the courts to take suo motu notice. He said the MQM-P has demanded a Karachi province, not a Muhajir province, described the PPP as a linguistic party, and claimed that 97 percent of Sindh's revenue comes from urban areas where 65 percent of the province lives.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Gohar asks Bilawal, other leaders to explain how to reset system

The PTI chairman says Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's warning of a collapsing system came late, while Bilawal says nothing can be settled without the PTI.

PoliticsSindhHow the reports differ

MQM-P demands Sindh chief minister resign over governance failures

Party spokesperson cites 48 percent of children with development delays, 44 percent out of school in several districts and about 6,000 children affected by HIV/AIDS.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

PML-N forms liaison committee to consult parties on new provinces

Senior PML-N leaders will approach the PPP, MQM Pakistan and every party in the House, as Bilawal Bhutto Zardari warns Sindh will not be divided by force.

PoliticsSindhHow the reports differ

Bilawal warns blood will flow in Karachi if Sindh is divided

The PPP chairman questioned the constitutional basis of Mohsin Naqvi's referendum proposal and said neither the prime minister nor the provinces had consulted the president or him.

EconomySindhHow the reports differ

Dar puts Pakistan's natural resources at $8 trillion to $10 trillion

Speaking at a Karachi ceremony for Turkey's seismic vessel Oruç Reis, the deputy prime minister said government debt stands near $100bn against resources he valued at up to $10tr.

DevelopmentSindhHow the reports differ

Sindh cabinet approves 500 electric buses for Karachi

The Rs37.97 billion deal with Heavy Industries Taxila covers 17 routes, three depots and 125 charging units, decided at a 21-point meeting chaired by Murad Ali Shah.

EconomySindhHow the reports differ

Turkish survey vessel Oruç Reis docks in Karachi for offshore search

The ship will collect 2D and 3D seismic data at two sites inside Pakistani waters, with Energy Minister Alparslan Bayraktar due at a port ceremony on Friday.

PoliticsSindhHow the reports differ

Sindh Assembly unanimously passes anti-terrorism law amendment

The bill designates an in-charge judge where a district has more than one anti-terrorism court and sets a 10-day deadline for agreeing a panel of judges.