Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

Bilawal rejects referendum on new provinces, warns of bloodshed in Sindh

The PPP chairman says the constitution already sets out how a province can be split and accuses a federal minister of forcing the issue.

Skardu Times desk
Bilawal rejects referendum on new provinces, warns of bloodshed in Sindh
Photo: Aaj News

PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said on Tuesday the party would not back any route to new provinces that bypasses the constitution, and warned that forcing Sindh's division would leave blood on Karachi's streets.

He was speaking to reporters in Karachi about a proposal by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, who said at a media talk in Islamabad on 12 November that surveys showed most people favour new provinces and that the question should go to a referendum. Naqvi said he would accept a vote against the idea completely.

Bilawal said the debate had been forced on the country for months and that neither parliament nor the federal cabinet had taken it up. "If the cabinet has not even considered the matter, how is it possible that a federal minister keeps pushing the same position?" he asked. He said he wanted Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to succeed but that the prime minister should have the authority to control his own minister.

On the referendum, Bilawal said the real question was intent, not procedure. The constitution already sets out how a province can be split, he said, and anyone looking for another route was seeking an unconstitutional path. "If you are looking for an unconstitutional way, the PPP cannot support you."

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar rejected the criticism. He said the discussion on provinces cannot be stopped and that democratic and legal requirements call for it to continue. If the people of Pakistan favour new provinces, "they should be made", he said, adding that public opinion cannot be ignored and a referendum is the best way to learn it. Tarar said talk of blood being spilled was beyond his understanding.

In Karachi, Sindh Senior Minister Sharjeel Inam Memon said the decision will be taken by the assemblies, not by referendum or a toss. Aaj News reported him saying that anyone could hold a hundred referendums but the constitutional procedure would still apply, and that rallies would need government permission. He also criticised the MQM, accusing it of reviving its founder's politics of fear.

Aaj News reported that MQM leader and federal health minister Mustafa Kamal proposed a referendum himself a day earlier, calling December an important month and saying a vote would be held if parties do not agree to a constitutional amendment.

Express News reported Farooq Sattar calling Bilawal's bloodshed remarks a conspiracy to incite riots in Sindh, saying Sindh has had the most corrupt government for 18 years and that a Karachi administrative unit would be named after Liaquat Ali Khan.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif told Geo News on 15 November that political consensus on new provinces can be built and that the constitutional court can be approached if the referendum's status is unclear. He said a "new system" could emerge by the start of the new year. Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Ahmed Khan backed the idea on 13 November and said the constitutional court may need to settle whether elected representatives can vote against a referendum result.

Under Article 239(4), a constitutional amendment altering a province's boundaries needs two-thirds approval in that provincial assembly and in the National Assembly. Article 48(6) lets the prime minister put a matter of national importance to a joint sitting of parliament and then to a referendum.

Former attorney general Ishtar Ausaf told BBC Urdu a referendum is neither parallel to nor a substitute for the constitutional procedure. PILDAT head Ahmed Bilal Mehboob said no constitutional or legal provision binds lawmakers to a referendum result.

How the reports differ

BBC Urdu led with Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's Karachi press conference and carried the constitutional detail, quoting Article 239(4) and Article 48(6) and interviews with former attorney general Ishtar Ausaf and PILDAT's Ahmed Bilal Mehboob. Aaj News led with Sindh Senior Minister Sharjeel Inam Memon's rejection of the referendum, and was alone in reporting Mustafa Kamal's own referendum proposal the previous day, his claim that December could be the month and his prediction that the PPP would change its position. Express News led with Farooq Sattar, who called Bilawal's bloodshed remarks a conspiracy to incite riots in Sindh and said a Karachi administrative unit would be named after Liaquat Ali Khan, details the other two did not carry.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Tarar calls referendum lawful route to decide on new provinces

Information minister says no party should object to asking voters directly, and that Sindh's people should decide whether they want more provinces.

PoliticsPakistan

Sanaullah says Bilawal's amendment remarks may invite disqualification

The prime minister's adviser on political affairs says the PPP chairman's account of the 27th Amendment vote raises questions about his own eligibility for office.

PoliticsSindhHow the reports differ

MQM-P demands Sindh chief minister resign over governance failures

Party spokesperson cites 48 percent of children with development delays, 44 percent out of school in several districts and about 6,000 children affected by HIV/AIDS.

PoliticsPakistan

Ayaz Sadiq says Mohsin Naqvi works on assigned tasks

The National Assembly Speaker says he will not judge the proposed 28th Amendment, and the President House denies new-province talks at the Zardari-Naqvi meeting.

DevelopmentSindhHow the reports differ

Sindh puts domicile and PRC certificates online with new portal

Chief Secretary Asif Haider Shah says applicants can file through a mobile app and processing time falls from about a week to a few hours.

HealthSindh

AKUH doctors flag diabetes risk among younger adults in Pakistan

Hospital roundtable hears that 34.5 million Pakistani adults live with diabetes, 9.3 million of them undiagnosed, with the count projected to reach 70.2 million by 2050.

SecuritySindhHow the reports differ

Fire breaks out at Baldia Town factory during oil tank refilling

Rescue 1122 says two tenders went first and more were called in; police and rescue officials report no casualties at the site.

PoliticsSindhHow the reports differ

Sindh Public Service Commission dismisses three recruitment officers

The commission says the three were removed and an assistant penalised with two annual increments after complaints were verified and records scrutinised.