Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

Court rules pension restoration must follow retiree age formula

A two-member bench set aside Lahore High Court judgments in four appeals by 1997 golden handshake retirees of the Punjab Road Transport Corporation.

Skardu Times desk
Court rules pension restoration must follow retiree age formula
Photo: UrduPoint

The Federal Constitutional Court has ruled that a uniform 15-year period for restoring the commuted portion of a pension cannot be applied to every retired employee, and that the period must be worked out from the retiree's age at retirement under the Punjab Civil Services Pension Rules, 1963.

A two-member bench of Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi and Justice Muhammad Karim Khan Agha gave the verdict in four appeals by former employees of the Punjab Road Transport Corporation, setting aside judgments of single and division benches of the Lahore High Court.

The appellants retired under a golden handshake scheme in 1997, taking half their pension as a lump sum and receiving the other half monthly. They argued that the commuted portion should have been restored in 2012, fifteen years after retirement, rather than in 2017, and sought five years of outstanding benefits.

They relied on the case of another retired employee, Mian Muhammad Ishaq, who was granted restoration after 15 years, and argued that the same treatment should extend to them.

The court held that the decision in Ishaq's case settled the matter only between the parties to it and did not establish a binding principle for all PRTC employees.

Under Rules 8.11 and 8.12 of the 1963 rules, the court said, the restoration period is calculated from the pensioner's age at retirement and the relevant commutation table. Differences in restoration periods that follow from differences in retirement age do not amount to discrimination under Article 25 of the Constitution, it held.

The judgment said that setting aside the high court's decisions would not take away the employees' legal entitlement to restoration. Each pension must be restored under the prescribed formula, with arrears and applicable annual increases paid wherever they are legally due.

The court converted the four petitions into appeals and allowed them through a short order dated September 23, 2026. It passed no order on costs.

EducationPakistan

HEC opens undergraduate scholarships for Balochistan, former FATA students

Applications for the fifth batch close on December 14, 2026, with half the awards reserved for Balochistan and half for the former FATA.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Imran Khan seeks court intervention, minister calls letter an NRO bid

Imran Khan says he is held alone 22 hours a day and his blood pressure reached 193; Tariq Fazal Chaudhry says he is the country's most facilitated prisoner.

EconomyPakistan

Digital payment transactions cross 4.2 billion in fourth quarter

The State Bank's annual report puts the value of the quarter's payments near Rs60 trillion, with e-wallet, mobile banking and card users all rising during FY26.

SecurityPakistan

Rights group logs 84 forced conversion cases in ten months

The Centre for Social Justice says Punjab recorded 47 of the cases against Sindh's 36, reversing a five-year pattern in which Sindh accounted for most reports.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

Government cuts petrol and diesel prices by Rs 2 a litre

Petrol will sell at Rs 328 per litre and high-speed diesel at Rs 358 from 17 November, after a three-day order that had set petrol at Rs 330.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

KSE-100 climbs more than 1,800 points as oil prices fall

The benchmark touched an intraday high of 179,692.98, with banks, cement and energy stocks leading after crude slipped and Gulf shipping reports improved.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Pakistan takes ECO chair as PM presses regional security cooperation

Shehbaz Sharif told ECO foreign ministers in Islamabad that disputes should be settled through dialogue, and welcomed the meeting's closing document and 2026-2035 economic goals.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

Fewer Pakistanis go abroad for work as Gulf hiring slows

BEOE figures show 476,238 workers left for jobs abroad in January-October 2026, against 763,536 in the whole of 2025, with Qatar and Bahrain taking far fewer.