Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

Federal Constitutional Court rebukes LDA over Rashid Minhas family litigation

A three-judge bench dismissed the authority's appeal against a 2018 Lahore High Court ruling and told it to stop wasting public money on frivolous cases.

Skardu Times desk
Federal Constitutional Court rebukes LDA over Rashid Minhas family litigation
Photo: Daily Times

The Federal Constitutional Court has directed the Lahore Development Authority to stop spending public money on what it called "frivolous, vexatious and obnoxious" litigation against individuals, in a judgment that closes a long dispute over a plot claimed by the family of Pilot Officer Rashid Minhas Shaheed.

A three-member bench headed by Justice Ali Baqar Najafi, with Justices Rozi Khan Barrech and Syed Arshad Hussain Shah, dismissed the LDA's appeal against a March 5, 2018 Lahore High Court judgment passed in favour of Farooq Minhas, the Nishan-i-Haider recipient's brother. The judgment, authored by Justice Najafi, was released on Tuesday, Daily Times reported.

"We, therefore, deem it appropriate that, instead of imposing costs, we direct the Director General, LDA, to ensure that the authority does not deplete its resources or public money on frivolous, vexatious and obnoxious litigation against individuals," Justice Najafi wrote.

The dispute concerns a 14-marla plot in Gulberg-III, Lahore. Farooq Minhas obtained a consent decree in his favour on May 7, 2005. When he moved to execute it, the LDA objected, saying the land was evacuee property acquired for the Gulberg-III scheme, that its predecessor, the Lahore Improvement Trust, had paid the award amount to the custodian of evacuee property and taken physical possession on Dec 24, 1955, and that the plot fell within a notification of Aug 6, 1953, with an award finalised on Oct 30, 1962. The authority also questioned Maqsooda Begum's purchase of the property from Nawab Mirza through a sale deed of March 7, 1976.

The executing court, the revisional court and the high court all rejected those objections, Business Recorder reported. The Supreme Court later dismissed the LDA's petition against the high court ruling, holding that the authority had no ownership rights over the land because the Settlement Department had already transferred it to the occupants.

The Federal Constitutional Court noted that the consent decree had been passed on the LDA's own no-objection, and that the objections raised under Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure were frivolous and beyond the scope of an executing court. It also cited an Aug 17, 1980 decision of the Vigilance Commission that duly verified transfer orders would be honoured and only development charges recovered from transferees, a decision the authority had accepted and acted on.

Justice Najafi observed that the family had faced "the agony perpetuated by the LDA by dragging them in the courts in frivolous litigation", according to Daily Times.

Pilot Officer Rashid Minhas was awarded the Nishan-i-Haider, the country's highest military gallantry award.

How the reports differ

Dawn and Daily Times led on the court's language, with both quoting the direction against "frivolous, vexatious and obnoxious" litigation; Daily Times also carried Justice Najafi's line that the family faced "the agony perpetuated by the LDA" and reported that the judgment was released on Tuesday. Business Recorder alone named the full bench, listing Justices Rozi Khan Barrech and Syed Arshad Hussain Shah alongside Justice Najafi, and set out the procedural history from the 2005 consent decree through the high court ruling and the Supreme Court's later dismissal of the LDA's petition. Dawn's report was available only as a headline and standfirst, so its fuller account could not be compared.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Gohar asks Bilawal, other leaders to explain how to reset system

The PTI chairman says Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's warning of a collapsing system came late, while Bilawal says nothing can be settled without the PTI.

SecurityPakistanHow the reports differ

US court sentences Pakistani national to 330 months over Trump plot

Asif Merchant, 48, was convicted in March of plotting to kill US political figures in revenge for Qasem Soleimani's killing; Iran denies the allegations.

EconomyPakistan

Pakistan sets five-year target of $1bn in gemstone exports

SAPM on Energy Zafar Iqbal told an Islamabad workshop the country holds about $450bn in gemstone reserves but ships only $5.8m a year in formal exports.

HealthPakistan

Ahsan Iqbal backs One Health plan and joint steering committee

The planning minister gave in-principle approval after a briefing that the project, launched in 2025, has finished a quarter of its activities.

HealthPakistan

PMDC sets February 8, 2027 deadline for doctor licence renewals

The council is trying to find out how many of more than 35,000 doctors with lapsed registrations still practise, and will strike off names left unrenewed for over 10 years.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

Shehbaz orders port modernisation and a bigger national shipping fleet

The Prime Minister's Office said the PNSC reform plan aims to raise Pakistan's sea cargo capacity to global standards by 2030.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Tarar calls referendum lawful route to decide on new provinces

Information minister says no party should object to asking voters directly, and that Sindh's people should decide whether they want more provinces.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

Cotton sowing reaches 82.8% of FY27 target, arrivals up 7%

Cultivation of 1.79 million hectares leaves a 370,000 hectare gap, while Sindh's 2.744 million bales led factory arrivals ahead of Punjab's 1.999 million