Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

Federal Constitutional Court strikes down Sindh, KP infrastructure cess

A two-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan set aside high court rulings that had upheld both provincial levies on goods.

Skardu Times desk
Federal Constitutional Court strikes down Sindh, KP infrastructure cess
Photo: Dawn

ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court on Thursday set aside the infrastructure cess levied by the Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa governments, holding the two provincial laws beyond legislative competence and striking down the high court judgments that had upheld them.

A two-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan, also comprising Justice Aamer Farooq, announced the reserved verdict. The short order was read in court, and the detailed judgment had not been released or posted on the court's website, Business Recorder reported.

Dawn reported that the bench had taken up a batch of 568 petitions by private petitioners against the high court decisions.

Sindh's levy dates to 1994. The Sindh Development and Maintenance of Infrastructure Cess Act, 2017 was enacted with retrospective effect from 1 July 1994, and the Sindh High Court upheld it in a judgment dated 4 June 2021. The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Infrastructure Development Cess Act, 2022 imposed a cess on the transportation and movement of goods in the province. Section 14 of the KP Finance Act, 2024 amended Section 3 of the 2022 Act, raising the rate from 1% to 2% and widening its scope. The Peshawar High Court dismissed 157 petitions against the KP levy on 14 November 2025 and upheld it.

Makhdoom Ali Khan, Raashid Anwer and Khalid Jawed Khan represented the Sindh petitioners, and Isaac Ali Qazi appeared for the KP petitioners, Business Recorder reported. The petitioners argued that the provinces had no constitutional authority to impose fiscal levies on imports, exports and goods in the federal legislative domain, and that the laws encroached on Parliament's exclusive competence under Article 142(a) and Entries 27 and 43 of the Federal Legislative List.

Hafiz Ehsaan Ahmad Khokhar, appearing for the Secretary Revenue Division and the Federal Board of Revenue, submitted that a levy's constitutional character turns on its true nature, taxable event, fiscal incidence, charging provisions and actual operation rather than on its name. Under Article 142(a), he argued, Parliament alone may legislate on matters in the Federal Legislative List, and a provincial charge operating through the customs-clearance mechanism falls in that domain.

Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa defended the laws as provincial levies meant to finance infrastructure and road facilities, not customs or export duties, and said their assemblies were competent to legislate under Article 142(c). The Additional Attorney General supported the Federation's position.

The ruling settles the division of taxing powers between the Federation and the provinces, and touches customs-related levies, inter-provincial trade and the movement of goods across Pakistan.

How the reports differ

Dawn alone reported that the bench had taken up a batch of 568 petitions and named Justice Aamer Farooq as the second judge. Business Recorder carried the legislative detail the other report did not: the rise in the KP cess rate from 1% to 2% under the 2024 Finance Act, the retrospective date of 1 July 1994 for the Sindh levy, and the 157 petitions the Peshawar High Court dismissed on 14 November 2025. Business Recorder also named the counsel on both sides and noted that only the short order was read. Both reports agreed on the outcome and gave the chief justice's name with different spellings.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

FBR notifies faceless appeals for sales tax, drafts income tax version

Sales tax and federal excise rules take effect on dates the FBR will announce; the income tax chapter remains a draft open to objections for three days.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

FBR orders tea makers to install production monitors by December 10

The order, STGO 35 of 2026, names 14 manufacturers and packers including Tapal and Mezan and requires every retail pack to be recorded before it leaves the factory.

PoliticsIslamabadHow the reports differ

Opposition leaders ask constitutional court to release detained KP chief minister

The joint petition names eight provincial assembly members and six MNAs, while a separate PTI filing seeks production of the KP assembly speaker.

EconomyPakistan

German importers' body and APTMA agree to lift textile trade

VFI managing director Michael Arretz says the German government-funded association represents more than 300 companies and favours Pakistan as China's textile environment shifts.

SportsPakistanHow the reports differ

Pakistan declared blind Asia Cup champion after Dhaka final is washed out

The match referee decided the title on league standings, net run rate and head-to-head record; India's blind cricket association called the outcome disputed.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Musadik Malik in Delhi for SCO forum as India disputes snub claim

Indian outlets, citing sources, said a culture ministry director and a foreign ministry under secretary received him, contradicting analyst Khurram Abbas's airport claim.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

Large-scale manufacturing grows 2.07% in first quarter

Automobiles and wearing apparel lifted output in July-September while food, textiles and pharmaceuticals contracted, provisional PBS data show.

PoliticsPakistan

Mushahid calls PM's Russia visit chance to reset ties

Former senator tells a United Russia conference in Moscow that Islamabad also expects Vladimir Putin for the 2027 SCO summit.