Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

International Commission of Jurists says amendments left top courts under executive control

The report says the 26th and 27th amendments removed safeguards required under international law, as the PTI demands the PPP explain its role in passing them.

Skardu Times desk
International Commission of Jurists says amendments left top courts under executive control
Photo: Geo News

The International Commission of Jurists has concluded that the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments left Pakistan's Supreme Court, high courts and Federal Constitutional Court without the guarantees of independence required under international law.

The report, released on Wednesday, found that the cumulative effect of the amendments and their implementation is that the highest courts no longer meet Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights or the UN Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary, Geo News reported.

"The 26th and 27th amendments have done exactly what we feared: they have placed Pakistan's highest courts under the control of the executive," the commission's secretary-general, Santiago Canton, said. "When the courts are captured, no one is left to hold the government to account, and victims of human rights violations have nowhere to turn."

The report examines the framework governing the high courts, the Supreme Court and the Federal Constitutional Court a year after the 27th Amendment passed in November 2025 and two years after the 26th Amendment passed in October 2024.

The 26th Amendment removed the Supreme Court's suo motu powers, set the chief justice's term at three years and let the prime minister choose the next chief justice from the three most senior judges. The 27th Amendment established the Federal Constitutional Court, changed the military's chain of command and granted immunities to senior government officials.

The commission said the amendments also impaired the right of victims of human rights violations to an effective remedy, guaranteed by Article 2(3) of the ICCPR, to which Pakistan is a party, and by domestic law. It recommended revising or repealing provisions in the two amendments that conflict with international standards on judicial independence.

Canton said the judiciary had needed reform, with judges appointed without transparency and courts at times overstepping into the domain of other institutions. "None of these problems has been fixed. Instead, the Government used people's legitimate frustration with the courts as a pretext to bring them under its full control," he said.

The PTI attacked the same amendments a day earlier, questioning PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari's criticism of the political and economic situation and asking him to explain his party's role in passing the 26th Amendment and its continued support for the ruling coalition.

In a statement issued in response to Bilawal's press conference, the PTI said the PPP could not distance itself from the country's worsening political and economic condition while remaining part of the coalition that sustains the arrangement. It accused the PPP of taking the privileges of power while disowning the government's failures.

The party held the PPP and the PML-N jointly responsible for economic deterioration and challenged Bilawal to back the restoration of reserved seats claimed by the opposition. It said attempts to exclude it from the political process would fail, called Imran Khan the representative of millions of Pakistanis and said negotiations were not possible without addressing its demands.

The PTI accused the authorities of political victimisation, intimidation and coercion, and said the way forward lay in restoring the public mandate, upholding constitutional supremacy and the rule of law. It asked Bilawal to explain the PPP's role in sustaining the arrangement he now questions.

How the reports differ

Business Recorder carried only the PTI's statement and did not report the International Commission of Jurists' findings on the same two amendments. Geo News and the Express Tribune both led on the jurists' report, with Geo naming Secretary-General Santiago Canton and carrying his quotations, while the Express Tribune put the report's conclusion on judicial independence in its headline.

PoliticsPakistan

Bilawal calls PTI a political reality as PML-N minister hits back

The PPP chairman told the Karachi Press Club the 27th Amendment was forced through, and warned that dividing Sindh would bring bloodshed in Karachi.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Gohar asks Bilawal, other leaders to explain how to reset system

The PTI chairman says Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's warning of a collapsing system came late, while Bilawal says nothing can be settled without the PTI.

PoliticsPakistan

Sanaullah says Bilawal's amendment remarks may invite disqualification

The prime minister's adviser on political affairs says the PPP chairman's account of the 27th Amendment vote raises questions about his own eligibility for office.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Khawaja Asif predicts new provinces deal and new system by new year

The defence minister says parties are weeks from agreement on new administrative units and that PTI founder Imran Khan could return to mainstream politics if he accepts.

SecurityPakistan

Asif cites 237,000 Pakistanis who served in UN peace missions

At the Schuman Security and Defence Forum in Brussels, the defence minister said 183 Pakistani peacekeepers had died across 48 missions over seven decades.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

FBR authorises seven more vendors for beverage production monitoring

The order binds more than 54 manufacturers of bottled water, juices, milk and aerated drinks to install systems whose output data is sent to the tax office.

PoliticsPakistan

Government will facilitate Imran Khan surgery if doctors advise, says Rana Sanaullah

The prime minister's adviser on political affairs says no negligence has been shown in the PTI founder's treatment, as the Islamabad High Court orders specialist doctors and facilities for Bushra Bibi in Adiala jail.

EconomyPakistan

Pakistan, Maldives set up joint working group to lift trade to $200m

Maritime Affairs Minister Junaid Anwar Chaudhry says a Pakistani delegation of economic and industrial representatives will visit the Maldives soon as a follow-up.