Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

Khawaja Asif questions Bilawal on Sindh's 18-year record

The defence minister said the PPP has held Sindh for 18 years and takes the gains of the federal coalition while the losses fall to the PML-N.

Skardu Times desk
Khawaja Asif questions Bilawal on Sindh's 18-year record
Photo: UrduPoint

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif asked PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari whether 18 years of his party's rule had turned Sindh into "a paradise", and whether the condition of Karachi made the world envious, in a post on X reported by UrduPoint.

The post followed a press conference by Bilawal that UrduPoint described as forceful and focused on the current government, and in which he spoke of a system collapse.

Asif said the PPP has been a partner of the PML-N in the federal government since 2022 and asked who had benefited and who had carried the loss. He said the PPP kept the gains while the losses were borne by the PML-N or by Pakistan as a whole.

"Mr Bilawal, you have been in power in Sindh for 18 years. Has Sindh become a paradise, and does the condition of Karachi make the whole world envious?" Asif asked, according to UrduPoint. He said anyone seeking justice should come with clean hands, and asked whether Bilawal's own hands were clean and whether he had the right to lecture or threaten others.

Asif said accountability of politicians was nothing new and that no political leader was exempt from it. If Bilawal was speaking of a system collapse, he said, everyone associated with that system was obliged to assess their own responsibilities.

He said seeking public support should not be called a backdoor route, because public opinion was the true foundation of politics, and that debate in Parliament together with an understanding of public opinion was the high point of democracy.

He said the rulers' power was held in trust for the people and was nobody's inheritance, and that the people's rights should not be confined to the pages of the Constitution. He said his aim was to improve the lives of Pakistanis so that ordinary citizens could live with dignity.

Asif said the real struggle now was to devolve governance to neighbourhood level, where Parliament and the public had an essential constitutional and democratic role. He said it was clear to everyone in which period Pakistan had received respect and esteem on the diplomatic and military fronts.

Dunya News, in the headline it published, framed the same post as mockery of Bilawal and strong criticism over Sindh's situation.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Talal Chaudhry attacks Bilawal over Sindh rule and new provinces

The minister of state for interior says the PPP holds about 70 percent of governance yet speaks like an opposition party, and Saeed Ghani calls the row a political spectacle.

PoliticsPakistan

Bilawal calls PTI a political reality as PML-N minister hits back

The PPP chairman told the Karachi Press Club the 27th Amendment was forced through, and warned that dividing Sindh would bring bloodshed in Karachi.

PoliticsPakistanHow the reports differ

Asif tells Bilawal to show clean hands before claiming equity

Defence minister cites the PPP's 18 years in Sindh and its federal partnership with the PML-N since 2022 in a second day of coalition exchanges.

PoliticsPakistan

Sanaullah says Bilawal's amendment remarks may invite disqualification

The prime minister's adviser on political affairs says the PPP chairman's account of the 27th Amendment vote raises questions about his own eligibility for office.

SecurityPakistan

Asif cites 237,000 Pakistanis who served in UN peace missions

At the Schuman Security and Defence Forum in Brussels, the defence minister said 183 Pakistani peacekeepers had died across 48 missions over seven decades.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

FBR authorises seven more vendors for beverage production monitoring

The order binds more than 54 manufacturers of bottled water, juices, milk and aerated drinks to install systems whose output data is sent to the tax office.

PoliticsPakistan

Government will facilitate Imran Khan surgery if doctors advise, says Rana Sanaullah

The prime minister's adviser on political affairs says no negligence has been shown in the PTI founder's treatment, as the Islamabad High Court orders specialist doctors and facilities for Bushra Bibi in Adiala jail.

EconomyPakistan

Pakistan, Maldives set up joint working group to lift trade to $200m

Maritime Affairs Minister Junaid Anwar Chaudhry says a Pakistani delegation of economic and industrial representatives will visit the Maldives soon as a follow-up.