Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

Pakistan rejects loan-based climate recovery at COP31 talks

Climate minister Musadik Malik told a Pakistan Pavilion session that Rs8 trillion of the Rs16 trillion the state collects goes to servicing debt.

Skardu Times desk
Pakistan rejects loan-based climate recovery at COP31 talks
Photo: Associated Press of Pakistan

Pakistan told the COP31 climate conference in Antalya that debt-stressed, climate-vulnerable countries cannot rebuild after disasters or meet their Paris Agreement commitments by borrowing more, with Federal Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination Dr Musadik Malik declaring that the country's "shop is closed for debt".

Malik was speaking at the Pakistan Pavilion in a session titled "Adapting Under Austerity: Delivering Paris Commitments in Debt-Stressed, Climate-Vulnerable Economies: A Parliamentary Perspective", organised by the Parliamentary Forum on Energy and Economy with the Asian Peoples' Movement on Debt and Development. The conference runs from November 9 to 20 at the Antalya EXPO Center in Türkiye.

He said international assistance to developing countries had fallen by 23% in a single year, taking it back to 2015 levels, while negotiators argued over pledges to triple it. The minister said the instruments on offer, among them green sukuk, blended finance and green bonds, were all forms of debt. Of the Rs16 trillion Pakistan collects, Rs8 trillion goes to debt servicing, he said.

Malik said rebuilding after the 2022 floods would cost about 9% of gross domestic product, and that the world's answer had been $8 billion to $10 billion in repurposed loans originally meant for health and education. Over the past five floods, he said, 6,000 people died, 20,000 were injured or disabled and 40 million were affected or displaced.

He said ten countries produce 70% of greenhouse gas emissions and receive 80% of green finance. "Financing is chasing emissions, not vulnerability," he said. Of the Loss and Damage Fund, he said $822 million had been pledged and $422 million collected, but that no money had reached affected communities.

Pakistan was pressing ahead with its own resources, he said. Citizens and farmers have installed an estimated 33 to 37 gigawatts of rooftop solar, and clean sources make up 55% of the energy mix, against a target of 70% to 75% in the next few years.

Dr Nafisa Shah, a member of the National Assembly and co-convenor of the forum, said parliaments had to be at the centre of the climate-fiscal debate because they pass budgets, oversee spending and voice public concerns. She said the 2022 floods affected about 33 million people and caused more than $30 billion in losses, with much of the reconstruction financed by borrowing. "Communities that contributed almost nothing to the climate crisis are being asked to rebuild their lives through additional debt," she said, calling it a "climate-debt trap". She called for grants, concessional finance, climate-resilient debt clauses, debt swaps, rechannelling of Special Drawing Rights, guarantees and effective access to the Loss and Damage Fund.

Minister of State for Climate Change Dr Shezra Mansab Ali Khan Kharal said 284 early-warning stations built with UNDP support now protect about 700,000 people in Gilgit-Baltistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and that more than one million climate-resilient homes have been completed in Sindh for flood-affected families, with ownership rights granted to women. The federal Climate Budget Statement had already mapped more than 5,000 cost centres for climate spending, she said.

Danyal Chaudhry, MNA and Parliamentary Secretary for Information and Broadcasting, said climate finance should not create additional debt vulnerabilities for countries already under fiscal pressure. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif made a similar call at a high-level session of COP31 last week, seeking grant-based financing and a significant increase in funds for resilience and adaptation.

How the reports differ

Business Recorder carried the session's full title and the figures the other two reports did not: the 23% fall in assistance, the Rs16 trillion collected against Rs8 trillion in debt servicing, and the $822 million pledged to the Loss and Damage Fund against $422 million collected. It also named Dr Nafisa Shah, Dr Shezra Mansab Ali Khan Kharal and Danyal Chaudhry, none of whom appear in the APP report. APP led on the minister's charge that the climate finance system had failed to deliver and gave his name as Dr Musadik Malik, where Business Recorder gives Dr Musadik Masood Malik, while The Nation led on the demand for grant-based finance with the least detail of the three.

ClimateTürkiyeHow the reports differ

Guterres presses climate finance pact as COP31 opens in Antalya

The UN secretary-general said emissions hit a record in 2025 and set a $300bn annual finance target for 2035, while Nepal pressed for a Himalayan agenda.

ClimateNepalHow the reports differ

Nepal glacier flood kills more than 1,400, thousands missing

Nepal's foreign minister asked the UN loss and damage fund for $20m; its board set aside $21.6m, about 0.7% of the country's economic losses.

ClimateTurkeyHow the reports differ

COP31 leaders split on fossil fuels as Antalya talks turn to drafting

Small island states demanded rapid emissions cuts while Venezuela defended its oil industry and Britain backed a Turkish plan to electrify 35 per cent of world energy use by 2035.

ClimatePakistanHow the reports differ

Shehbaz reaches Antalya to press climate finance demand at COP31

The prime minister addresses the leaders' summit on Wednesday and is expected to meet heads of government, with Pakistan asking rich states for predictable, accessible funding.

SecurityPakistan

Field Marshal Munir meets Iran's Araghchi on regional security

ISPR says the Rawalpindi meeting covered shared security challenges and evolving geopolitical developments; Araghchi praised Pakistan's role in regional stability.

EconomyPakistan

Current account posts $39mn surplus as remittances rise 14%

October's surplus follows a revised $371mn deficit in September, with workers' remittances of $3.89bn cushioning a trade gap that widened 9% year on year.

EconomyPakistanHow the reports differ

KSE-100 climbs 1,154 points in early trade, extending Monday's rise

The benchmark index stood at 179,337.26 by 9:35am, with buying in banks, cement and energy stocks, as Asian markets fell on new US chip curbs.

EconomyPakistan

Pakistan invites Turkmenistan to join CASA-1000 power project

Power Minister Awais Leghari also pressed Turkmenistan to expedite technical data for the TAP line from Afghanistan to Quetta.