Skip to content
Skardu TimesSkardu Times

LHC rules private DNA test cannot overturn child's legitimacy

Justice Asad Ali Bajwa dismissed a father's challenge to maintenance and dowry orders, holding that a privately obtained UK lab report cannot defeat the legal presumption.

Skardu Times desk
LHC rules private DNA test cannot overturn child's legitimacy
Photo: Minute Mirror

The Lahore High Court has ruled that a DNA test arranged privately by a father cannot displace the legal presumption that a child born during a valid marriage is legitimate, and has dismissed his challenge to maintenance and dowry orders passed for his minor son.

Justice Asad Ali Bajwa upheld the enhanced maintenance award and the direction to recover dowry articles. The petition was filed by Usama Tahir, named in the judgment as living in the United Kingdom, against Zainab Irfan and others. Dawn reported that he had challenged concurrent decisions of a Gujranwala family court and an additional district and sessions judge on maintenance and dowry. Zainab Irfan and her son had filed a suit for maintenance, dower and dowry articles.

According to the judgment, the couple married on 18 August 2019 and their son was born on 27 April 2022, while the marriage was intact. The father produced a report from a private laboratory in the United Kingdom that reportedly excluded him as the child's biological father. The court found no evidence that any competent court had ordered or supervised the test.

Article 128 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, the court held, makes the legitimacy of a child born during a valid marriage a conclusive presumption, subject to exceptions recognised in law. Members of the father's family admitted during proceedings that the marriage was intact when the child was born, the judgment records.

The court said paternity disputes, particularly those involving minors, require careful handling, and that a child's dignity, privacy and emotional well-being must be protected. DNA testing should not become a routine exercise and must serve the child's best interests, it said. Judicial scrutiny is required, and neither a party's demand nor the availability of scientific facilities is enough to order a test. Even parental consent does not remove the court's duty to assess whether testing is in the child's interest.

The judgment found that the test had been arranged without judicial permission and without the mother's consent, and referred to Articles 4, 9 and 14 of the Constitution, which protect liberty, privacy and dignity from unlawful interference.

It cited the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1962, and the Supreme Court's ruling in Ghazala Tehsin Zohra v. Mehr Ghulam Dastgir Khan, observing that the principle set out there requires a Muslim father contesting a child's paternity to do so within a maximum of 40 days after the birth.

PoliticsPunjab

LHC rejects foreign ministry report on two PTI workers held in UAE

The court summoned the official handling the file after finding the ministry's response fell short of its September 14 order to decide the representations within 15 days.

SportsPunjabHow the reports differ

Pakistan bowl Sri Lanka out for 98 in Rawalpindi Test

Aaj News reported Pakistan closed day one on 121 for 3, a lead of 23, after bad light cut play short; Express News said the lead had passed 100

PoliticsPunjab

Azma Bokhari says Imran Khan sought NRO in writing

Punjab information minister calls the former prime minister's letter on his jail medical treatment propaganda and lists specialist examinations since August 2024

PoliticsPunjabHow the reports differ

Punjab reverses Rawalpindi police chief posting within hours

Sardar Ghiyas Gul is named city police officer after Muhammad Sohail Ashraf had been appointed, with Hassan Mushtaq Sukhera moved to CTD Punjab.

SportsPunjabHow the reports differ

Pakistan bowl Sri Lanka out for 98, lead by 23 at stumps

Mohammad Abbas, Razaullah and Aamer Jamal took three wickets each in Rawalpindi as Sri Lanka were dismissed in 35.3 overs on the opening day.

EconomyPunjabHow the reports differ

Punjab minister touts industrial policy, announces Gujranwala industrial park

Shafay Hussain told an exhibition at Lahore's Expo Centre that industrial plots are now leased for 30 to 50 years, and announced a 250-acre park in Gujranwala.

DevelopmentPunjab

Punjab to launch Khushaal Dehat Programme in 1,985 villages

The first phase covers 485 villages; a partial restriction on cooperative societies in force for 29 years is to be eased to let villagers run the work.

SecurityPunjabHow the reports differ

Punjab to set up speedy courts for crimes against women and children

Maryam Nawaz orders AI-assisted investigation and recorded evidence after an IG report shows close relatives are involved in 71% of abuse cases